How Mr Live Shopping Scores Whatnot Sellers

Verified August 1, 2026. Refreshed Monthly.

A seller score should be reproducible. It should not be a popularity contest or a paid endorsement disguised as research.

Eligibility

A seller is not scored until the record contains:

  • Profile URL
  • Category
  • Rating and rating count
  • Sold count
  • Average shipping time
  • Review date
  • At least two observed shows or a meaningful order sample
  • Disclosure notes
  • Pricing notes
  • Fulfillment notes
  • Conflict disclosure

Related reading: is Whatnot legitimate and safe.

Proposed score

AreaWeight
Listing and live disclosure25
Fulfillment and packaging20
Category expertise15
Price and value-claim accuracy15
Buyer support15
Auction and giveaway clarity10

Total: 100 points

For more detail, see how to spot counterfeit items.

Disclosure score

Review whether the seller states:

  • Exact product
  • Quantity
  • Condition
  • Flaws
  • Size or measurements
  • Authenticity basis
  • Included accessories
  • Shipping limits
  • Break or surprise rules

See also: Pokémon deal alerts.

Fulfillment score

Use:

  • Average shipping time
  • Packaging observations
  • Missing-item reports
  • Cancellation pattern
  • Defect reports
  • Seller response
  • Repeat consistency

Worth checking before you bid: sports card deal alerts.

Category expertise

Category expertise is demonstrated by accurate identification and useful answers, not by confidence.

Background: women's clothing deal alerts.

Price-claim accuracy

Record whether the seller uses:

  • Completed sales
  • Asking prices
  • Retail price
  • Graded value for raw items
  • Wrong product configuration
  • Unsupported appraisal

Useful next step: makeup deal alerts.

Support score

Review:

  • Response time
  • Clarity
  • Evidence requested
  • Resolution
  • Escalation
  • Pattern across cases

Freshness

Seller scores should include:

  • Last reviewed date
  • Number of observations
  • Category
  • Current confidence level

A score older than 90 days should be marked stale until refreshed.

Paid relationships

A seller may advertise with Mr Live Shopping, but:

  • Payment does not raise the score.
  • Sponsored placement is labeled.
  • Affiliate relationships are disclosed.
  • A seller can be removed after new evidence.
  • Review data remains separate from sales agreements.

Corrections

Sellers and buyers can submit corrections with evidence.

The page should keep:

  • Date
  • Claim
  • Evidence
  • Decision
  • Score change
  • Reviewer

Publication rule

Follow seller reviews: Subscribe by category for new and updated seller assessments.

Sources checked

Related Whatnot Guides

Get Pokémon deal alerts

Mr Live Shopping sends free alerts when noteworthy Whatnot shows go live in this category.

Pick your Pokémon deal alerts

Browse every Whatnot buyer guide